Page header image

Cases

This section contains details about Hearings to be held by the Standards Commission and the procedures to be followed. It also contains information about decisions the Standards Commission has made and any interim suspensions in place.

Our Cases

Information about cases referred to the Standards Commission, including scheduled and concluded Hearings are provided in the table below.

Hearings start at 9:30 unless otherwise stated.

If there is no entry in the Hearing Date / Time column, the date for the Hearing is still to be arranged. 

Press Releases are available to download within five working days of the conclusion of the Hearing.

Full Written Decisions are available to download within 10 working days of the conclusion of the Hearing. 

Information about Hearings & Cases will be kept for seven years from the date of the Standards Commission’s full written decision.  After this, details about the case will be removed from the website and will no longer be available, in line with the Standards Commission’s Document Retention Schedule.

In order to be as accessible as possible, the Standards Commission will hold the Hearing at a venue in the area of the headquarters of the Local Authority (where the Respondent is a councillor); or at the venue where the devolved public body holds its meetings (if the Respondent is a member of a devolved public body).

If any Hearing is to be held online it will be livestreamed. When a livestream is in progress, a link will be found here. You will need to click on the link taking you to our YouTube page.

While Hearings are normally open to the public and press, social distancing guidelines in place during the ongoing Covid-19 pandemic mean that the Standards Commission will have to limit the number of attendees at Hearings scheduled to be held in October, November and December 2020. If we are unable to accommodate the public and press we will livestream the Hearing and a link will be provided on this page of the website.

If we are able to accommodate the public and press, we will do so on a first come, first served basis. If you would like to reserve a place at a Hearing, please email: enquiries@standardscommission.org.uk with your name and the Hearing you wish to attend. We will then reply to let you know if you have been allocated a space at the Hearing. PLEASE NOTE YOU WILL NOT BE ALLOWED TO ATTEND IF YOU HAVE NOT RESERVED A SPACE.

Please note that we will publish a full written decision on the website following the conclusion of a Hearing. We will also prepare a press release. If you would like a copy of this to be emailed to you at the conclusion of the Hearing, please let us know.

Standards Commissions Scotland
Case Ref. Decision on Referral Respondent(s) Organisation Hearing Date/Time Venue Decision on Breach Decision on Sanction Press Release Written Decision
LA/DG/1929 Hearing Former Cllr Tom McAughtrie Dumfries & Galloway Council 13/02/18 Meeting Room 2, Council Headquarters, English Street, Dumfries, DG1 1DD Breach of paragraphs 3.1, 3.2 and 3.16 Censure Download PDF Download PDF
LA/Fi/2044 Hearing Councillor Tim Brett Fife Council 05/02/18 Fife House, North Street, Glenrothes, KY7 5LT Breach of paragraph 3.16 Censure Download PDF Download PDF
LA/E/2028 Hearing Cllr Frank Ross City of Edinburgh Council 29/11/17 City Art Centre, 2 Market Street, Edinburgh, EH1 1DE Breach of paragraphs 4.2 and 4.20 Censure Download PDF Download PDF
LA/AB/1967, LA/AB/1969, LA/AB/1972/A,B, LA/AB/1979/A,B,C and LA/AB/1986 No Action Cllr Roderick McCuish & Cllr Richard Trail Argyll & Bute Council 02/10/17 N/A as no Hearing Download PDF
LA/R/1946 &1973 Hearing Cllr Paul Mack Renfrewshire Council 23/10/17 Renfrewshire Council, Renfrewshire House, Cotton Street, Paisley, PA1 1TR Breach of paragraph 3.2 Suspension Download PDF Download PDF
LA/ED/1863 Hearing Cllr Eric Gotts East Dunbartonshire Council 22/08/17 Enterprise House, Strathkelvin Place, Kirkintilloch G66 1XQ Breach of paragraphs 3.3, 3.5, 3,14 and 3.15 Censure Download PDF Download PDF
LA/G/1942 Hearing Cllr William McAllister Glasgow City Council 26/07/17 Glasgow City Chambers, George Square, Glasgow G2 1DU Breach of paragraphs 3.1 and 3.2 Censure Download PDF Download PDF
LA/E/1924 Hearing Cllr Jim Orr City of Edinburgh Council 11/07/17 Lothian Valuation Joint Board, 17a South Gyle Crescent, Edinburgh EH12 9FL Breach of paragraphs 3.1 and 3.2 Censure Download PDF Download PDF
LA/As/1963 & 1993 Hearing Cllr Alexander Duncan Aberdeenshire Council 21/06/17 Aberdeenshire Council, Woodhill House, Westburn Road, Aberdeen, AB16 5GB Breach of paragraphs 3.16, 3.19 and 7.10 Suspension Download PDF Download PDF
LA/NL/1936 Hearing Cllr Marina Lyle North Lanarkshire Council 05/06/17 Motherwell Concert Hall and Theatre, Windmillhill St, Motherwell, ML1 1AB Breach of paragraphs 4.18 and 4.19 Censure Download PDF Download PDF
LA/WL/1824 Hearing Cllr Angela Moohan West Lothian Council 24/05/17 West Lothian Council, West Lothian Civic Centre, Howden South Road, Livingston, EH54 6FF Breach of paragraphs 4.2, 5.7 and 5.10 Censure Download PDF Download PDF
LA/E/1737 & LA/E/1751 Hearing Cllrs Cameron Rose and Jeremy Balfour City of Edinburgh Council 19/05/17 Mezzo Suite, Usher Hall, Lothian Road, Edinburgh EH1 2EA No Breach Download PDF Download PDF
LA/NL/1940 Hearing Cllr Rosa Zambonini North Lanarkshire Council 06/04/17 North Lanarkshire Council, Dalziel Building 7 Scott Street, Motherwell, ML1 1PN Breach of paragraphs 4.3 and 4.7 Censure Download PDF Download PDF
LA/PK/1948 Referral withdrawn by CESPLS - see press release Cllr Kathleen Howie Perth and Kinross Council 01/01/17 Not Applicable - see press release Download PDF
NB/SFRS/1919 Hearing Mr Neil Pirie Scottish Fire and Rescue Service 01/03/17 East Service Centre of the Fire and Rescue Service, 21 Claylands Road, Newbridge, EH28 8LF No Breach Not applicable - see Written Decision Download PDF Download PDF